Your first 90 days as a new F&I manager: a survival plan
What to focus on in month one, two and three, the mistakes that cost new F&I managers their seat, and a daily routine that keeps you out of trouble.
Camila VenegasUpdated November 20265 min read
As a new F&I manager, focus first on clean paperwork and fast funding, then on lender relationships and a consistent menu, then on your numbers. Most new F&I managers struggle because deals don’t fund, not because they can’t sell. Build a daily routine around contracts in transit, stips and a menu for every customer.
Why do the first 90 days matter so much?
You finally got the seat. Now every deal feels like a test, the sales desk is watching your speed, and the GM is watching your numbers. That pressure is normal.
In my 17 years in the car business, the new F&I managers who made it weren’t the best talkers. They were the ones whose deals funded. Get the basics right first, and the numbers follow.
Days 1 to 30: how do you get clean deals and fast funding?
- Learn your dealership software and every lender portal you’ll use
- Check every contract against the deal before the customer signs
- Track every deal until the lender pays, not just until delivery
- Learn your store’s written compliance process and follow it every time
- Ask the office staff what usually goes wrong, then prevent it
Days 31 to 60: how do you build lenders and a consistent menu?
- Study the program sheets for your top three lenders
- Introduce yourself to each lender’s rep and funding desk
- Present the same menu to every customer, the same way
- Practice honest answers to the objections you hear most
- Learn the DTI and PTI math well enough to structure deals before you send them
A consistent menu protects the customer and protects you. Read the F&I menu, explained in plain English.
Days 61 to 90: which numbers should you know?

- Your PVR (F&I income per retail deal) compared to the store average
- Your product penetration for each product
- How many deals are in transit and how many days they’ve been waiting
- Your chargebacks so far, and why they happened
Pick one number to improve next month and ask your manager for feedback. Understand how these numbers affect your check in F&I pay plans explained.
What does a good daily routine look like?
- Start the day with your contracts-in-transit list
- Clear open stips before new customers arrive
- Review yesterday’s deals for missing signatures or documents
- Present a menu to every customer
- End the day by checking what funded and what didn’t
If a deal is stuck, start with what stips are and how to clear them fast.
What mistakes cost new F&I managers their seat?
- Rushing paperwork to keep up with the desk, then losing days in funding
- Skipping the menu with some customers, which is inconsistent and risky
- Promising a payment before the lender approves it
- Fighting with the sales desk instead of solving the deal together
- Ignoring chargebacks until they show up on your check
Every one of these is avoidable with a routine and a little patience. You’re building trust, and trust is built one funded deal at a time.
Start with the rules that shape every deal in F&I compliance basics.
Frequently asked questions
How long does it take to feel comfortable as a new F&I manager?
It varies. Many new managers feel more confident after a few months, once they know their lenders and their store’s process. A daily routine speeds it up.
What should I do when a deal won’t fund?
Find out exactly why. Call the funding desk, clear the missing stip or fix the document, and resubmit the same day if you can.
Should I keep notes on each lender?
Yes. Write down each lender’s limits, common stips and funding contacts. Your notes become your fastest tool.
How do I build trust with the sales desk?
Be fast, be clear about what you need, and never surprise them. When a deal has a problem, bring a solution with the bad news.




